By Natalie Lozano Trimble
Photography by Thanin Viriyaki
If you’re headed to the Hill Country and want to avoid I-35, you’ll probably drive through Hico, about an hour and a half from Fort Worth. The city holds a mystique, says Jenn Hunter, who co-owns the Midland Hotel and Chop House with her husband, Eric. Locals say that when Billy the Kid disappeared from history, he quietly settled here.
The draw for the Hunters was what this community of 1,300 doesn’t have: lots of people or traffic. They like the pace, and they’re in good company: nearby Wiseman House Chocolates has called Hico home since 1996, and Oma Leen’s has been one block south on Pecan Street since 2023.
The Midland Hotel and Chop House first opened in 1896 and was in operation for about 4 decades before it sat empty for 75 years. It reopened in 2017 after renovations.
Jenn runs the hotel, Eric says, but he unclogs drains and fixes doorknobs as needed.
“I’m a hostess at heart for sure,” Jenn says. She worked for Grace’s owner, Adam Jones, who was then at Del Frisco’s, for nine years before working at Lonesome Dove and later Reata. Many of the people she’s met in those places have been repeat customers at the Chop House, she says, and she and Eric love heading back to Fort Worth to see their mentors when they can.
Initially, Jenn came to Hico kicking and screaming because she loves Fort Worth. “Now you can’t get me to leave Hico,” Jenn says.
Scratch comfort food is what you’ll find at the Chop House: chicken fried steak, fried chicken, both ribeye and filet steaks, lamb shank and weekly seafood specials like gumbo.
Eric’s favorite offering is turkey necks with collard greens. “It takes some doing to get people to order it, but they always like it,” he says. “People get thrown off by the word ‘neck.’”
He sources the menu’s herbs from raised beds behind the restaurant, which he also shares with everyone in town since he has more than they need, he says.
Eric, who grew up in Saginaw, started his culinary career in Augusta, Georgia, then worked at Atlanta’s Spice for Paul Albrecht, who became his mentor.
When he returned to Fort Worth, he joined Lonesome Dove, where he hired a young Juan Rodriguez as his sous chef before Rodriguez went with Tim Love to New York City.
Hunter eventually headed west to open Fire Oak Grill in Weatherford as executive chef. He and Jenn first met at the White Elephant Saloon and married in 2010, then bought the restaurant from the original owner the same year.
Ten years and one venture in Louisiana later, Eric and Jenn found themselves doing a trial run at the Chop House on Valentine’s Day 2020. Two weeks later they agreed to come aboard, but that March, the restaurant had to shut down because of COVID-19. They reopened in May.
Jenn found that many people in small towns like Hico were still getting out. “It felt safer, more open air, that type of thing,” she says.
Since then they’ve stayed busy. “Hico is kind of an anomaly,” Eric says. “It didn’t make sense that we were doing the kind of business that we were doing.”
He says the city should be billed as a brunch destination with great options available Sunday mornings, including the Chop House, with shopping and free live music Sunday afternoons at HiCo Hall.
The Hunters opened a second restaurant in March of this year. The Sidecar Smoke Shack serves traditional Texas barbecue with scratch-made sides in Hico’s old Chevron station.
The Midland Hotel is open seven nights a week with 14 rooms and since there are only a few other lodging options available in town, making a reservation in advance is recommended.
The Sidecar Smoke Shack is open for breakfast and lunch Tuesday through Saturday and the Chop House is open for lunch and dinner Thursday through Saturday, with brunch offered on Sunday.
Find the recipe for smoked turkey necks with braised collard greens and sidecar vinegar-molasses bbq glaze here.
